Skip to main content

What to do if you think your sibling is spending your parent's money

Your brother has had power of attorney for Dad's finances since the stroke four years ago. You trusted him with it because he lives twenty minutes from Dad and you live in another province. Lately the numbers don't add up. Two withdrawals last month, a few hundred dollars each, no label, no explanation you've heard. You haven't said anything yet. You've just been doing the math in your head for three weeks straight, and it's starting to poison every phone call you have with him.

This is one of the ugliest spots in caregiving. Raising it can wreck a relationship even when you're right. Staying quiet can cost your parent real money even when you're wrong to suspect anyone. Before you say a word to your brother, it helps to know what the law actually requires of him, and what you yourself are allowed to ask for.

The duty he already has, whether he's told you or not

Under Ontario's Substitute Decisions Act, an attorney for property owes your parent a duty of honesty and good faith, and a separate duty to account for every transaction. That second duty isn't optional, and it doesn't depend on anyone asking for it. A regulation under that same act spells out what the records actually have to contain: a list of your parent's assets from the day the power of attorney took effect, every transaction since, the date of each one, the reason for it, and who the money went to or came from. Bank statements alone don't satisfy this. He's supposed to be keeping a running ledger, not a shoebox of receipts he'll sort out later.

Most attorneys, including well-meaning ones, have never read this regulation. They assume good intentions cover it. Legally, they don't, and that gap is where a lot of families end up.

What your parent can still ask for, if they're able to

If your dad is still mentally capable, the cleanest fix doesn't involve you at all. He's the one who granted the power of attorney, and he's entitled to ask his attorney to walk him through the accounts whenever he likes. Most parents never think to ask. Some are too polite. Others handed off the finances specifically so they wouldn't have to think about money again. A gentle nudge, something like "have you ever had Mark walk you through the statements," can settle this without you ever voicing a word of suspicion.

What you can ask for, and where that runs out

Here's the part that stings. As a sibling with no legal role in Dad's finances, you don't have an automatic right to see the books. Being worried doesn't create authority. You can still ask your brother directly for an informal walkthrough, and a sibling with nothing to hide usually says yes without much fuss. One who gets defensive, vague, or angry at the question is handing you information too, just not the kind you can take to a bank.

If that conversation goes nowhere and the concern is real, your options move outside the family. Ontario's Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee investigates when someone may be incapable and at risk of serious financial harm from the person managing their money, and you can bring your concern to them. There's also the option of applying to the court to compel your brother to formally pass his accounts, a process that forces a complete accounting under oath. Courts have ordered attorneys to repay money, and to cover the cost of the proceeding, once the accounting turned up real problems. Neither route is pleasant. Neither should be your opening move. Both exist for exactly this situation.

Keep your own record starting today

Whatever you decide, start writing things down now, before any of this gets confronted head-on. Dates. Amounts. What Dad said about a specific withdrawal. What your brother said when you brought it up. Memory softens details and second-guesses itself under pressure. A dated note in your phone doesn't.

It's also worth naming the quieter cost here. Even if this resolves cleanly, something between you and your brother will have shifted, because you asked the question at all. That's a real loss, and it's still smaller than the one you're trying to prevent.

What to do this week

  • If your parent is still capable, ask whether they've looked at the account records lately, and offer to sit with them while they ask for a look.
  • Write down the specific transactions that worried you, with dates and amounts, before the details blur.
  • Ask your sibling for an informal walkthrough of the accounts before assuming the worst. Pay attention to how they respond, not only what they say.
  • Look up Ontario's Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee on ontario.ca now, so you already know how to reach them if the next step becomes necessary.
  • Hold off on accusing anyone until you've actually seen a number that doesn't add up. A wrong guess can cost you a sibling you'll still need for the next ten years of this.